This is no time for despair. There is a way to unseat Gianni Infantino.

The FIFA president is not eligible to run again under the statutory term limits.

By Miguel Maduro and Nick McGeehan

The knives have been out for Gianni Infantino ever since the FIFA President’s botched effort to sell off the rights to FIFA tournaments to Trump-adjacent private equity. Numerous football associations have withdrawn their support for Infantino, who is set to stand again for the FIFA Presidency in March 2027. UEFA has gone so far as to prepare criminal proceedings against Infantino with a view to discovering internal documents that they presumably hope will leave Infantino’s position untenable, and sources unknown continue to feed the media damaging revelations aimed at ending Infantino’s tenure at the top of the global game. 

None of it seems to be working. “We reaffirm our full commitment, of course, to supporting you”, said the head of the Asian Football Confederation, Sheikh Salman Al-Khalifa to the FIFA President at an extraordinary AFC congress in Tokyo recently. It was a remarkable turnaround from the man who co-signed a letter as recently as August calling on Infantino to resign and saying he had broken trust “through deception” and “placed himself above the collective”. You could almost hear the sound of the collective sigh of resignation, as people around the world accepted football’s fate – four more years for President Infantino.

At this juncture, it is imperative that we say again – and encourage those seeking Infantino’s ouster to do likewise – that it does not need to be like this, for the simple reason that Gianni Infantino is very obviously not eligible to run again for the FIFA Presidency. 

One of the reforms that FIFA announced in 2016 in the aftermath of the last scandal to rock football’s world governing body related to presidential term limits, which serve as a check on executive power and are a cornerstone of good governance. The rule that FIFA introduced is as clear as can be in article 33(2) of the FIFA statutes: “No person may serve as President for more than three terms of office.” Gianni Infantino was elected FIFA President at an Extraordinary FIFA Congress in February 2016 and has since been re-elected in June 2019 and in March 2023, making this his last term in office. 

The FIFA press release that laid the ground for a fourth term of office was released two days before the final of the 2022 men’s World Cup in Qatar. “The FIFA Council…unanimously confirmed its agreement with the view of the Governance, Audit & Compliance Committee that the period between 2016 and 2019 does not count as a term of office for the current FIFA President, who is therefore about to end his first term.” 

FIFA has never explained why and how the Governance Committee came to this view, nor what is the legal basis for the involvement of the FIFA Council at all. Under FIFA’s rules it is for a Review Committee to assess the eligibility of any candidate (including the current President) and it is only the FIFA Congress that is competent to amend the limit of three terms of office. The decision is clearly unlawful, as we have argued in detail in a complaint we recently submitted to the competent FIFA Bodies. Our view is supported by independent legal experts such as Malte Frank, who warned immediately after FIFA’s decision that it “violates the FIFA statutes in both form and substance and is therefore most likely void”. As a result, member associations can challenge not only the decision but also the upcoming election, which would leave the football community in a state of legal uncertainty.

Gianni Infantino has been on the campaign trail: at the opening game of the U-15 World Cup with Azerbaijan’s head of state Ilham Aliyev (l) and in Bhutan (r).

Quite simply, any member association that does not support Infantino has the power to instigate a process that has a very strong chance of leading to his removal. The failure of the people who run the game to pursue this means of ousting such a tarnished incumbent says much about the dysfunctional governance system that put Infantino in power in the first place. It suggests that the current challenges to Infantino’s rule are more of a power play than a genuine effort to reform FIFA.

To take the most obvious example, why has UEFA, which has sought to claim the mantle of reform, missed such an open goal in not advising its member associations to challenge Infantino’s eligibility? The most obvious explanation lies in Aleksander Čeferin’s announcement in early October that will run for a fourth term of office as UEFA President. UEFA may have changed its rules to make a fourth presidential term possible, but this is a gross violation of the spirit of football’s rules on term limits. When the rules were amended two years ago Ceferin said he would not run for a fourth term of office and expressed outrage at those who had raised the possibility the amendment was done to allow him to do so. 

UEFA’s failure to invoke the rule-book is therefore not surprising, but in any case UEFA is not a member of FIFA, and the power to unseat the president rests with any one of its 211 national member associations. The blueprint is there in the form of FairSquare’s formal complaint to the Governance, Audit and Compliance Committee of 13 August. The three members of that committee charged with ruling on the eligibility of candidates for the FIFA presidency responded to the complaint and said that they would “read and consider the points FairSquare raises in due time.” Bruno Chiomento and Chris Mihm, the chair and deputy chair of the Governance Committee, have built their professional reputations in arenas where commitment to responsible governance is a sine qua non. Should they fail to respond to pressure from member associations to apply the rules, this could be challenged before the Court of Arbitration for Sport.

The Norwegian Football Federation has intervened twice already this year and called on both FIFA’s Ethics Committee and its Governance Committee to demonstrate their commitment to the rule book and transparency. Debbie Hewitt of the English FA sat down with the BBC a few weeks ago to relay the message that Infantino is “not fit to be the FIFA President”. 

If that is the case – and it very obviously is – then invoke the rule book, point out that he is very clearly and very obviously ineligible, and begin the process of his removal. The football world will owe a debt of gratitude to the associations that grasp this mantle.

Parliamentarians, other public authorities and civil society organizations can also ensure that pressure is brought to bear effectively by insisting that their national member associations take an effective stance against this gross abuse of presidential power. This is no time to play ball with FIFA and UEFA’s self-serving and specious arguments on political neutrality. FIFA’s serial misgovernance affects all levels of the game everywhere and Infantino’s brazen misconduct is the opportunity for politicians to make their voices heard and to show they are serious about promoting governance reform of sport. 

Miguel Maduro is the former chairman of Fifa’s governance committee and Dean of the Catolica Global School of Law. Nicholas McGeehan is the director of FairSquare and its rebootfifa.com campaign.

Josimar regularly opens its columns to independent guest contributors who wish to comment on the most pressing issues in world football. These columns solely reflect the opinion of their authors. Their publication does not constitute an endorsement on Josimar’s behalf, but a way to encourage and promote debate within the football community.

Zeen is a next generation WordPress theme. It’s powerful, beautifully designed and comes with everything you need to engage your visitors and increase conversions.